Updated · LootCue Editorial Team

How to choose game, band and pop-culture merch

Compare merch shops on product range, official licensing, sizing, shipping countries, returns and support before you order a shirt, poster or collectible.

What this kind of merch covers

Game, band and pop-culture merch covers shirts, hoodies, posters, prints, mugs, plush and small collectibles tied to video games, bands, films, comics and anime. The same design can reach you through a licensed official store, a general retailer or an independent artist’s print shop.

That mix is why two items that look alike can differ in quality, rights and returns. It helps to know which kind of seller you are dealing with before you pay.

What decides value

The first question is licensing. Official merch is made with the rights holder’s approval, while independent designs are often fan-made, and some copies are unlicensed altogether. Next is the range: whether the shop covers your game or band, and in the product type you want.

Then look at sizing, print and material quality, shipping countries, the return window and support. Apparel and posters have different risks. A shirt can fit badly, and a poster can arrive creased or in the wrong size.

How Redbubble, Geeksoutfit, Kinokuniya and Spencers Gifts differ

Redbubble is a US company founded in 2006 that sells apparel and posters and art. It gives a 30-day returns window and offers support by email and a help centre. It does not list its products as officially licensed, so check each listing for who made the design and what rights it carries.

Geeksoutfit is a Hong Kong based store that sells apparel and game merch and lists a very long set of shipping countries. It gives a 30-day returns window and offers support by email and a help centre.

Kinokuniya is a US-based bookstore business whose categories include figures, plush, posters and art, anime merch and mystery boxes. It lists markets across Asia, Oceania and North America, takes preorders, gives a 30-day returns window and has support by email, phone and a help centre. Spencers Gifts is a store founded in 1947 that serves the US and Canada and sells apparel.

Official, fan-made and unlicensed merch

Official merch usually names the licence holder on the product page, the label or the packaging. Fan-made designs from independent artists can be good and original, but they may not carry any licence, and a listing should say so. Unlicensed copies are the risk to avoid. They often show rough prints, wrong colours and thin fabric.

Buy from the maker, the rights holder’s store or a seller that states clearly where its products come from. Compare photos with the official art, check the seller’s name and read the reviews for comments on print quality.

Sizing, print and materials

Check the size chart on each listing, because sizing differs between makers and between product lines. Look at the fabric description and the print method. Prints that sit on the surface of the fabric can crack over time, while designs woven or dyed into the cloth tend to last longer. Wash instructions help you keep the design intact.

For posters and prints, check the paper size, the finish and how the order is packed. A tube protects a poster from creases, while a flat mailer may not. Frames and mounts are often sold separately.

What to check before you order

Look at where the order ships from and how long it takes. Merch that comes from another country may face import charges, and a tracked service helps if a parcel goes missing. Read the returns policy for printed-to-order items, because some shops treat them differently from stock items.

Check support channels too. Email and a help centre are common, while phone and chat are less so. If you buy a mystery box, remember that you do not know what is inside, so set a limit before you order.

How to shortlist

Pick the game, band or film first, then decide whether you want official merch or are happy with independent designs. Choose two or three shops that carry it and ship to you, and compare sizing information, return windows and support. The game, band and pop-culture merch ranking sets these shops side by side.

See the full ranking: Top game, band and pop-culture merch compared →

Sources