Troll and Toad review
Updated October 1, 2026 · LootCue Editorial Team · Facts checked October 1, 2026
We earn a commission when you sign up through links on this site. Partner status can affect where a brand appears in our rankings.
Our verdict
Troll and Toad is a United States trading card store for collectors who want to buy the usual card lines and sell an older stack in the same place. Its buylist takes old cards, board games and video games, and questions are answered by email.
Key facts
- Best for
- A United States store for buying new cards and selling an old collection.
- Buys your cards
- Yes (Source, checked April 29, 2026)
- Headquarters
- United States (Source, checked April 29, 2026)
- Support channels
- Email (Source, checked October 1, 2026)
- Card games
- Pokemon, Magic, Yugioh, One piece, Lorcana
- Official website
- trollandtoad.com
Apps and profiles
- Elsewhere
- facebook.cominstagram.com
Pros and cons
Pros
- It runs a buylist, so you can hand the store your old cards, board games and video games instead of approaching buyers one at a time.
- The range covers Pokémon, Magic: The Gathering and Lorcana, so a collection spanning a few games can be ordered together in the same basket.
- Everything runs from the United States, so listings, stock and pricing all sit in the same domestic market.
Cons
- Support runs on email, so a question about an order waits for a written reply rather than a call.
- The operation is based in the United States, so a shopper in another country is left to sort delivery times and any charges on the way.
Who it suits
- Collectors who want to restock and send an old collection to the same store.
- Fans who shop across a few trading card lines and would rather place a combined order than hunt game by game.
- Sellers clearing board games or video games alongside a stack of old cards.
Who should look elsewhere
- Collectors whose shelves are mostly sports cards, with the range here built around the trading card games the store sells.
- Shoppers who want help by phone, since support runs on email.
- Readers outside the United States who want delivery terms settled before ordering.
Who runs it
Troll and Toad is a trading card store based in the United States, running its business from an address in North Carolina rather than a spread of local shops. Questions reach the company by email, and that inbox is the route for anything to do with an order, a delivery or a sale. Support is written rather than spoken, which suits a buyer who is content to keep the full exchange in a thread and suits a buyer who wants to talk a problem through far less.
How Troll and Toad compares


Plarium







Starforged
Crossout
Star Stable
War Thunder
Enlisted
Inn.games EU
Humbrol GB
GGPick
Woodestic
Perfect World RU
Norns
Vertexhub
Frequently asked questions
Which card games does Troll and Toad stock?+
Troll and Toad lists Pokémon, Magic: The Gathering, Yu-Gi-Oh! and more in its range, which covers the trading card games most collectors are buying. Several of those lines sit in the same basket, so a restock for a table of players can be placed together rather than game by game. It also makes a mixed collection easier to keep together in the same room.
Can I sell my old collection to Troll and Toad?+
Yes. The store runs a buylist, and it describes that side of the business as a hub where gamers sell old cards, board games and even video games. That makes it useful for a collector whose shelf is mixed, and a sale runs through the same the United States company that sells the new stock to buyers.
Where is Troll and Toad based?+
The store is based in the United States, with its operations run from an address in North Carolina. Everything is handled through that base rather than a chain of shops, so a fan in another country is buying across a border. Delivery terms are worth confirming with the store before an order goes through, and the United States base handles the buying side too.
What does the Troll and Toad buylist take in?+
The buylist is the side of the business where the store takes in used collectibles: old cards, board games and video games. It sits alongside the retail side, so a seller can clear a mixed pile without chasing buyer after buyer. For a collector with a shelf full of mixed titles, that is a practical way to turn old stock into money.
How do I get help from Troll and Toad?+
Questions go by email to the store's support team, and that inbox is the route for anything about an order, a delivery or a sale. Replies come in writing, which works well for a buyer who wants a record of the answer and less well for a buyer who wants to sort a problem out in a call. The team works from the same the United States base as the store.
Does Troll and Toad buy and sell through the same company?+
The retail side and the buying side sit with the same company in the United States, which means a collector who buys cards can also send a stack of old ones to the same address. Sellers and buyers are dealing with the same team, and questions about either side go to the same inbox. That matters for a collector clearing a finished game and restocking a game still in play.
Is Troll and Toad a good fit for a collector outside the United States?+
Read it as a United States store first. Anything bought from another country is an order across a border, so delivery times and any charges on the way are worth putting to the store by email before you commit. Fans who need terms confirmed up front are better served by a seller in their own market.
Sources
- trollandtoad.com checked October 1, 2026
Backs: Support channels
“If you have any questions, feel free to reach out to our support team. support@trollandtoad.com”
- web.archive.org/web/20260429005938/https://www.trollandto... checked April 29, 2026
Backs: Buys your cards, Card games, Headquarters
“Troll and Toad's Buylist is a one stop hub for gamers to sell us their old cards, Board Games, and even Video Games!”
Compiled from 2 source pages, checked October 1, 2026. We did not open an account.
Not confirmed yet: Products.
Troll and Toad
A United States store for buying new cards and selling an old collection.